“Lawmakers have been discussing the penny’s growing losses for decades, and a number of them have put forward new legislation to end production of the cent,” says Caroline Turco, a curator at the Money Museum at the American Numismatic Association. (Numismatics is the study of coins, paper currency, and similar objects.)
Yet cost isn’t the only problem. Pennies are essentially worthless in value. Common coin-payment devices like vending machines and parking meters won’t accept them. Many products—from snacks to clothing—cost more than a dollar to buy. “There has never been a coin in circulation within the United States worth as little as a penny is in today’s economy,” says Turco. Digital transactions are another reason that pennies aren’t needed. In a 2024 survey by the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, people reported using cash for only 14% of their monthly purchases.
Without pennies, what happens when we do pay in cash? Registers will simply round transactions up or down to the nearest nickel. Nickels will work as the lowest-value coin, but for how long? After all, nickels cost even more to make than they’re worth—nine cents extra! Turco agrees that could be a problem. “I do think if the penny discontinuation goes smoothly, the nickel could be next,” she says.